MCA Reconciliation: Your Protection When Sales Fall

MCA Reconciliation: Your Protection When Sales Fall | HL Hunt

MCA Reconciliation: Your Protection When Sales Fall

Most merchant cash advances collect a fixed amount every day, even though the business sold a percentage of its receipts. Reconciliation is the clause that fixes the gap: when sales fall, it should refund the difference, about $2,400 in a $60,000 month in our example. Courts and the New York Attorney General treat it as what separates an advance from an illegal loan. Here is how it works.

By the HL Hunt Research Desk · 11 min read · Updated

The clause that makes an advance an advance

A merchant cash advance is structured as a purchase of a share of a business's future receipts, not a loan. The provider pays a lump sum today in exchange for a specified percentage of future receipts until a fixed purchased amount is collected. Because repayment is supposed to rise and fall with sales, and the provider bears the risk that sales decline, the transaction is treated in many states as a sale rather than a loan, outside usury laws that cap interest rates. The feature that makes this possible in practice is the reconciliation provision.

Most advances do not actually collect a percentage of each day's sales. For convenience, they collect a fixed daily or weekly amount, estimated from the business's average revenue. Reconciliation is the mechanism that keeps the arrangement honest: if the fixed payments exceed the agreed percentage of actual receipts, the business can request an adjustment, and the provider refunds the difference or lowers future payments. Without genuine reconciliation, a fixed payment is just a loan payment with a different label.

How reconciliation works, worked

Consider a business that receives $90,000 a month and sells 10% of its future receipts until a purchased amount is collected. Rather than sweeping 10% of daily deposits, the provider debits a fixed $400 every business day, about $8,400 a month, roughly 9.3% of expected receipts.

Monthly reconciliation refund owed when a fixed $400 daily debit exceeds 10% of actual receipts
Receipts of $90,000: 10% is $9,000: $0Receipts of $90,000: 10% is $9,000$0Receipts of $75,000: 10% is $7,500: $900Receipts of $75,000: 10% is $7,500$900Receipts of $60,000: 10% is $6,000: $2,400Receipts of $60,000: 10% is $6,000$2,400Receipts of $45,000: 10% is $4,500: $3,900Receipts of $45,000: 10% is $4,500$3,900

Computed by HL Hunt. The fixed debit totals $8,400 over 21 business days. Where it exceeds the 10% specified percentage of actual receipts, a genuine reconciliation provision should return the difference. Illustrative.

In a normal month, the fixed debit is below 10% of receipts and no adjustment is owed. If receipts fall to $75,000, 10% is $7,500, and the business has paid $900 more than the agreement allows. At $60,000, the overpayment is $2,400; at $45,000, $3,900. A genuine reconciliation provision, promptly honored, returns those amounts or reduces future debits, so that the business pays the agreed share of what it actually earned. That is the risk the provider accepted in exchange for its pricing. If reconciliation is unavailable in practice, the business pays $8,400 regardless, and the provider bears no sales risk at all.

Methodology and assumptions

The business, specified percentage and debit amount are hypothetical. Monthly fixed debits equal $400 times 21 business days. The refund owed equals the fixed debits minus 10% of actual monthly receipts, where positive. Actual contracts differ in how often reconciliation can be requested, what documentation is required and whether adjustments are refunds or reductions to future payments.

Why courts and regulators care

Whether an advance is a true sale or a disguised loan determines whether usury laws apply, how it is treated in bankruptcy and what remedies a business has. Courts look at the substance of the deal, and reconciliation is usually the first thing they examine. New York's Appellate Division, in a widely cited 2020 decision, identified three factors: whether there is a reconciliation provision, whether the agreement has a finite term and whether the provider has recourse if the merchant declares bankruptcy. A real, usable reconciliation right, an indefinite term and no recourse for ordinary business failure point toward a sale; a sham or burdensome reconciliation process, a fixed repayment schedule and full recourse point toward a loan.

Regulators have pursued providers whose reconciliation was illusory. In January 2025, the New York Attorney General obtained a $1.065 billion judgment against Yellowstone Capital and related companies, alleging that they promised reconciliation but used measures that made refunds practically unavailable, collected fixed daily amounts unrelated to revenue over short terms and charged effective annual rates as high as 820%. The settlement canceled more than $534 million in balances owed by over 18,000 businesses nationwide. An earlier action against Richmond Capital Group produced a judgment of more than $77 million. The message for providers is that reconciliation must be real, and for businesses that it is a right worth understanding before signing.

Percentage sweeps versus fixed debits

Not every advance relies on reconciliation. Some providers collect a true percentage of each day's card receipts directly through the business's card processor, a split that adjusts automatically: a slow day means a smaller payment, a busy day a larger one. Others sweep a percentage of all deposits into the business bank account. These structures make reconciliation largely unnecessary, because payments already track receipts. Fixed-debit advances are more common because they are simpler to administer across businesses with mixed payment channels, but they shift the burden of adjustment onto the business, which must notice the overpayment, document it and ask. When comparing offers, a business with volatile sales should weigh how payments actually behave in a slow month, not just the factor rate. A slightly more expensive advance that collects a true percentage can be safer than a cheaper one with a fixed debit and a cumbersome reconciliation process, and a line of credit or term loan, where available, avoids the question altogether.

What to look for in an agreement

  • A clear reconciliation process: how to request it, how often, what documents are needed, such as bank statements, and how quickly the provider must respond.
  • Refunds or reductions, not just discretion. Language that lets the provider decline adjustments at will undermines the right.
  • The specified percentage, stated clearly, so you can calculate whether fixed payments exceed it.
  • No fixed term or balloon, consistent with repayment that depends on receipts.
  • Default triggers. Many agreements treat a decline in receipts as permitted, but changing bank accounts, blocking debits or taking another advance as defaults. Know which is which.
  • Personal guarantees that cover performance, such as honest reporting, rather than repayment if the business fails, a distinction that matters for both the true-sale analysis and the owner's exposure; see personal guarantees.
  • Disclosures. In states with commercial financing disclosure laws, providers must disclose total cost, payment terms and in some states an estimated APR.

Compare advances and alternatives side by side

HL Hunt Funding is a business financing marketplace connecting businesses with providers of revenue-based financing, lines of credit, term loans and invoice factoring. Compare offers on cost, payment structure and terms before you commit.

Check Your Funding Options

Using reconciliation when sales fall

If revenue drops, a business with a genuine reconciliation right should act early. Gather bank statements showing actual receipts for the period, calculate the specified percentage of those receipts and compare it with the payments debited. Submit a written reconciliation request following the agreement's procedure, keep copies and track the response. Ask for future payments to be adjusted to the reduced level while receipts remain low. Do not simply stop payments or close the bank account, which most agreements treat as a default with serious consequences. If the provider refuses a properly documented request, that refusal may matter in any later dispute, and legal advice is worthwhile. Our guide to managing a revenue decline covers the broader steps, and cash flow forecasting helps anticipate slow periods before they arrive.

The provider's perspective

Providers point out that advances fund businesses that banks will not, often quickly and without collateral, and that their pricing reflects high loss rates. Many reputable providers honor reconciliation and adjust payments when sales fall, because doing so is both contractually required and commercially sensible: a business that survives a slow season can complete its payments. Fixed debits exist because daily percentage sweeps are operationally complex for businesses that do not process most sales through a single card processor. And some businesses abuse reconciliation by moving revenue to other accounts. These are fair points, and they explain why reconciliation requires documentation. But the economic case for treating advances as sales rests entirely on the provider genuinely sharing sales risk. Where it does, an advance can be a reasonable tool for businesses with variable revenue, particularly in seasonal industries such as the restaurants where advances began. Where it does not, the business has taken an expensive loan without the protections a loan would carry. Our explainers on merchant cash advances and revenue-based financing, and our guide to comparing offers, help businesses tell the difference.

Find financing that fits variable revenue

Apply once with HL Hunt Funding and review offers from multiple providers, so you can compare how each structure handles slow months before choosing.

Apply at HL Hunt Funding

Frequently asked questions

What is reconciliation in a merchant cash advance?

Adjusting fixed payments to match the agreed share of actual sales.

How much reconciliation could I be owed?

In the example, about $2,400 in a $60,000 month.

Why does reconciliation matter legally?

It is a key factor in whether an advance is a sale or a loan.

What happened in the Yellowstone Capital case?

A $1.065 billion judgment over illusory reconciliation and extreme rates.

Key takeaways

  • Merchant cash advances buy a percentage of future receipts but usually collect fixed daily amounts.
  • Reconciliation adjusts fixed payments to the agreed percentage of actual receipts.
  • In the example, a $400 daily debit overpays by $2,400 when monthly receipts fall to $60,000.
  • Courts weigh reconciliation, a finite term and bankruptcy recourse in the sale-versus-loan analysis.
  • New York obtained a $1.065 billion judgment against Yellowstone Capital over illusory reconciliation.
  • Check the process, specified percentage, default triggers and guarantee scope before signing.
  • Request reconciliation in writing with bank statements; do not stop payments unilaterally.

References

  1. LG Funding, LLC v. United Senior Properties of Olathe, LLC, 181 A.D.3d 664 (N.Y. App. Div. 2d Dep't 2020).
  2. New York State Office of the Attorney General (2025). Settlement and judgment against Yellowstone Capital and related entities.
  3. New York State Office of the Attorney General (2024). Judgment against Richmond Capital Group.
  4. New York C.P.L.R. § 3218 (confessions of judgment, as amended 2019).
  5. Uniform Commercial Code §§ 9-109 and 1-203 (sales of accounts and payment intangibles; leases versus security interests).
  6. Federal Trade Commission v. RCG Advances, LLC, et al. (S.D.N.Y., filed 2020), concerning merchant cash advance practices.
  7. Federal Reserve Banks. Small Business Credit Survey (annual reports), merchant cash advance usage.

This guide is educational and does not constitute legal or financial advice. Merchant cash advance agreements vary, and the true-sale analysis depends on state law and specific terms; consult an attorney. The example is hypothetical. HL Hunt Funding is a financing marketplace; offers are made by third-party providers under their own terms, HL Hunt may receive compensation from providers, and approval, amounts and terms are not guaranteed.