Commercial Real Estate Refinancing: Inside the Maturity Wall

Commercial Real Estate Refinancing: Inside the Maturity Wall | HL Hunt

Commercial Real Estate Refinancing: Inside the Maturity Wall

About $875 billion of commercial mortgages was scheduled to mature in 2026. Take an office loan of $10 million on a building now worth $9.75 million: a new lender will advance about $6.34 million, leaving the owner $3.66 million short. Here is where the stress sits, why lenders keep extending loans and why small businesses should pay attention.

By the HL Hunt Research Desk · 12 min read · Updated

The maturity wall

Commercial real estate debt does not amortize like a home mortgage. Most loans on offices, apartments, shopping centers, warehouses and hotels run five to ten years and leave a large balance due at the end, to be repaid by refinancing or selling the property. That structure works when values hold and rates are stable. It becomes a problem when a large volume of loans made at low rates and high valuations comes due after rates have risen and some property values have fallen. That is the "maturity wall" that has preoccupied lenders and regulators since 2023.

The Mortgage Bankers Association estimated that $875 billion of the roughly $5.0 trillion in commercial and multifamily mortgages outstanding at the end of 2025, about 17%, was scheduled to mature in 2026, down from $957 billion scheduled for 2025, with another $652 billion due in 2027. Depository institutions held the largest share of 2026 maturities, $396 billion, or 21% of their commercial mortgage balances. Loans in commercial mortgage-backed securities and similar vehicles had $200 billion maturing, 25% of their balances. By property type, 30% of hotel balances, 23% of industrial, 17% of office and 13% of multifamily were scheduled to mature during the year. Many of those maturities are loans already extended once or more, which is part of why the wall keeps rolling forward.

Where the stress is

The MBA's survey of loan performance found delinquency rising again in the third quarter of 2026. The delinquency rate on loans in commercial mortgage-backed securities reached 4.97% at September 30, up from 4.82% in the second quarter. Life insurance company portfolios rose to 1.33% and the multifamily portfolios of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to 1.16%, while the FHA portfolio improved to 0.90%. Office properties continued to show the highest delinquency rates of any property type. The contrast between securitized loans and portfolio lenders reflects both underwriting differences and the fact that securitized loans are harder to modify quietly, so their problems surface sooner.

Office is the center of the problem for structural as well as cyclical reasons. Gupta, Mittal and Van Nieuwerburgh estimated that the shift to remote and hybrid work reduced the value of New York City office buildings sharply, with the largest declines in older, lower-quality buildings, and argued that the losses would ripple through municipal finances. Higher-quality buildings with long leases have fared better. Multifamily, by contrast, faces mainly a rate problem: rents and occupancy are generally healthy, but loans made at very low rates must be refinanced at much higher ones.

Why refinancing fails, worked

Consider an office building bought in 2019 for $15 million with a $10 million interest-only loan at 4%, a loan-to-value ratio of 67%. The loan matures in 2026. Leasing has weakened, and the building is now worth $9.75 million, 35% less. At a 6.5% capitalization rate, that value implies net operating income of about $633,750.

A new lender willing to lend at 65% of today's value would advance at most about $6.34 million. Check it against income: at 7% interest on a 30-year amortization, a loan that keeps debt service coverage at 1.25 times is about $6.35 million, nearly the same figure. The existing loan is $10 million. To refinance, the owner must add about $3.66 million of new equity. If the owner cannot or will not, the options are an extension, a loan modification, a sale at a loss, or default.

Refinancing an office loan after a 35% fall in value
Loan balance due at maturity: $10.00MLoan balance due at maturity$10.00MProperty value today (was $15 million): $9.75MProperty value today (was $15 million)$9.75MMaximum new loan at 65% loan-to-value: $6.34MMaximum new loan at 65% loan-to-value$6.34MEquity the owner must add to refinance: $3.66MEquity the owner must add to refinance$3.66M

Computed by HL Hunt for a hypothetical interest-only office loan. A 1.25 debt service coverage test at 7% over 30 years on $633,750 of net operating income gives nearly the same maximum, about $6.35 million.

Even if the old loan were simply extended at a new rate of 7%, its $10 million balance on a 30-year schedule would require debt service of about $798,000 a year against income of $633,750, a coverage ratio of about 0.79. The property no longer earns enough to pay a market-rate loan of its original size. That arithmetic, repeated across thousands of buildings, is the maturity wall.

Methodology and assumptions

The purchase price, loan size, 4% original rate, 35% value decline, 6.5% capitalization rate, 7% refinance rate, 65% loan-to-value limit and 1.25 coverage requirement are illustrative. Net operating income is today's value multiplied by the capitalization rate. Actual outcomes depend on leases, location, lender appetite and the sponsor's resources; many loans are extended or modified rather than refinanced or foreclosed.

Banks and extend-and-pretend

Commercial real estate is the largest loan category for many community and regional banks, which is why the maturity wall is a banking story as much as a real estate one. Interagency guidance issued in 2006 flagged banks whose construction lending exceeds 100% of capital or whose total commercial real estate exposure exceeds 300% of capital, with growth of 50% or more over three years, for closer supervisory attention. Many smaller banks remain above those thresholds. The capital proposals described in our analysis of the bank capital overhaul would ease some requirements but do not change concentration expectations, and loan agreements with covenants on coverage and value give lenders an early say when a property weakens.

Faced with loans that cannot be refinanced, lenders often extend them, sometimes with paydowns or rate changes, rather than recognize losses. Regulators' 2023 policy statement on prudent loan accommodations and workouts recognized that well-structured modifications can be in both parties' interest. Critics call the practice "extend and pretend," because it can defer recognition of losses that will eventually come. Jiang, Matvos, Piskorski and Seru estimated that commercial real estate distress, combined with the decline in bank asset values from higher rates, could push a meaningful number of banks toward insolvency in a severe scenario, especially those with high uninsured deposits, as our analysis of bank runs discusses.

Why small businesses should care

The maturity wall matters to small businesses that never borrowed against an office building, through two channels. The first is credit supply. Chakraborty, Goldstein and MacKinlay found that when banks are heavily exposed to real estate, their lending to commercial businesses changes with real estate conditions; a bank absorbing losses on commercial property has less capital and attention for small business loans. Community banks, which make a disproportionate share of small business loans, are also the most concentrated in commercial real estate, as our analyses of bank mergers and the small business credit gap explain.

The second is opportunity. Falling office and retail values mean lower rents and more negotiating leverage for small business tenants, and some distressed properties are being converted or sold at prices that open space for new uses. Small business owners who own their buildings, often financed through the SBA 504 program, face their own refinancing questions when balloon payments come due. Our guide to collateral valuation explains how lenders reassess property values at refinancing.

Private credit steps in

As banks have pulled back from new commercial real estate lending, debt funds, insurance companies and other nonbank lenders have filled part of the gap, often with shorter, higher-rate loans or mezzanine and preferred equity that sits between the senior loan and the owner's equity. That capital helps some owners bridge the refinancing gap in the worked example, at a price. It also moves risk outside the regulated banking system, a trend our private credit outlook examines. The MBA's figures show credit companies, warehouse facilities and other lenders with $163 billion of 2026 maturities, 29% of their balances, the highest share of any group, a reminder that nonbank lenders face the wall too.

The case that it is manageable

Not everyone sees a crisis. Commercial real estate is not one market: industrial, multifamily and much of retail have performed far better than office, and office is a modest share of total commercial mortgage debt. Many loans have been extended or restructured without default, and lenders and borrowers have had years to prepare. Bank losses on commercial real estate, while real, have so far been absorbed by earnings and capital rather than causing failures on the scale of 2023. If interest rates decline, refinancing gaps narrow for every property type. On this reading, the maturity wall is a slow, painful repricing of one sector that will produce losses for specific owners and lenders but not a systemic event. Both readings agree that the outcome depends heavily on rates and on office demand, and that the losses will be concentrated rather than spread evenly.

Frequently asked questions

What is the commercial real estate maturity wall?

A large volume of loans due after rates rose and values fell.

Why can't some commercial properties refinance?

Lower values and higher rates shrink the new loan.

Which property types are most stressed?

Office, by a wide margin.

How does commercial real estate stress affect small businesses?

Through bank credit supply and lower rents.

Key takeaways

  • About $875 billion of commercial mortgages, 17% of balances, was scheduled to mature in 2026.
  • CMBS delinquency reached 4.97% in the third quarter of 2026.
  • Office shows the highest delinquency of any property type.
  • In the example, a $10 million office loan faces a $3.66 million refinancing gap.
  • Extended at 7%, the old loan would cover debt service only 0.79 times.
  • Banks heavily exposed to real estate may lend less to small businesses.
  • Outcomes depend mainly on interest rates and office demand.

References

  1. Mortgage Bankers Association. (2026, February 9). 17 Percent of Commercial and Multifamily Mortgage Balances to Mature in 2026.
  2. Mortgage Bankers Association. (2026, October 27). Commercial Real Estate Finance Loan Performance Survey, Third Quarter 2026.
  3. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, FDIC & OCC. (2006). Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending, Sound Risk Management Practices.
  4. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, FDIC, NCUA & OCC. (2023). Policy Statement on Prudent Commercial Real Estate Loan Accommodations and Workouts.
  5. Gupta, A., Mittal, V., & Van Nieuwerburgh, S. (2022). Work From Home and the Office Real Estate Apocalypse. NBER Working Paper No. 30526.
  6. Jiang, E. X., Matvos, G., Piskorski, T., & Seru, A. (2023). Monetary Tightening, Commercial Real Estate Distress, and US Bank Fragility. NBER Working Paper No. 31970.
  7. Chakraborty, I., Goldstein, I., & MacKinlay, A. (2018). Housing Price Booms and Crowding-Out Effects in Bank Lending. Review of Financial Studies, 31(7), 2806–2853.

This analysis is educational and does not constitute investment, lending or legal advice. Market figures are drawn from public sources and subject to revision. The worked example is hypothetical.